Legal & Technical Grounds for Refusal
Ground your remarks in these facts so the Board understands why the permit must be refused.
Prior-to conditions not met
Beedie had to clear every prior-to condition by Jan 15, 2024. They missed it, so the prior permit should be considered expired.
New application required
The 2025 submission is not the 2017 project. Floor space is up 7.8%, homes climb 20%, and height jumps 15 ft. That scale of change triggers a fresh application under the 2023 HA-1A zoning.
Height violations
The tower reaches 104 ft—that’s 6'11" above the HA-1A maximum of 29.6 m. The Board must enforce the absolute height limit in the district schedule.
Massive visual impact
An oversized glass dome and atrium pierce the height envelope and dominate Chinatown Memorial Square, a culturally significant gathering place.
Community space misrepresented
The so-called community space is buried in a service alley with no meaningful public access, turning a promised benefit into a token gesture.
Loading issues
Four of six retail units lack internal loading. Trucks would spill into Memorial Square, disrupting daily cultural and community use.